-
Business valuations
We offer expert valuation advice in transactions, regulatory and administrative matters, and matters subject to dispute – valuing businesses, shares and intangible assets in a wide range of industries.
-
Capital markets
You need corporate finance specialists experienced in international capital markets on your side if you’re buying or selling financial securities.
-
Complex and international services
Our experience of multi-jurisdictional insolvencies coupled with our international reputation allows us to deliver the best possible outcome for all stakeholders.
-
Corporate insolvency
Our corporate investigation and recovery teams can help you manage insolvency situations and facilitate the best outcome.
-
Debt advisory
An optimal funding structure for your organisation presents unprecedented opportunities, but achieving this can be difficult without a trusted advisor.
-
Expert witness
Our expert witnesses analyse, interpret, summarise and present complex financial and business-related issues which are understandable and properly supported.
-
Financial models
A sound financial model will help you understand the impact of your decisions before you make them. Talk to us about our user-friendly models.
-
Forensic and investigation services
We provide investigative accounting and litigation support services for commercial, matrimonial, criminal, business valuation and insurance disputes.
-
Independent business review
Is your business viable? Will it remain viable in the future? A thorough independent business review can help your organisation answer these fundamental questions.
-
IT forensics
Effective ESI analysis is integral to the success of your business. Our IT forensics experts have the technical expertise to identify, preserve and interrogate electronic data.
-
Mergers and acquisitions
Grant Thornton provides strategic and execution support for mergers, acquisitions, sales and fundraising.
-
Raising finance
Raising finance - funders value partners who can deliver a robust financial model, a sound business strategy and rigorous planning. We can guide you through the challenges that these transactions can pose and help you build a foundation for long term success once the deal is done.
-
Relationship property services
Grant Thornton offers high quality independent advice on the many financial issues associated with relationship property from considering an individual financial issue to all aspects of a complex settlement.
-
Restructuring and turnaround
Grant Thornton’s restructuring and turnaround service capabilities include cash flow, liquidity management and forecasting; crisis and interim management; financial advisory services to companies and parties in transition and distress
-
Transaction advisory
Our depth of market knowledge will steer you through the transaction process. Grant Thornton’s dynamic teams offer range of financial, commercial and operational expertise.
-
Corporate tax
Grant Thornton can identify tax issues, risks and opportunities in your organisation and implement strategies to improve your bottom line.
-
Employment tax
Grant Thornton’s advisers can help you with PAYE (payroll tax), Kiwisaver, fringe benefits tax (FBT), student loans, global mobility services, international tax
-
Global mobility services
Our team can help expatriates and their employers deal with tax and employment matters both in New Zealand and overseas. With the correct planning advice, employee allowances and benefits may be structured to avoid double taxation and achieve tax savings.
-
GST
GST has the potential to become a minefield and can be expensive when it goes wrong. Our technical knowledge can help you minimise the negative impact of GST
-
International tax
International tax rules are undergoing their biggest change in a generation. Tax authorities around the world are increasingly vigilant, especially when it comes to global operations.
-
Research and Development
R&D tax incentives are often underused and misunderstood – is your business maximising opportunities for making claims?
-
Tax compliance
Our advisers help clients manage the critical issue of compliance across accountancy regulations, corporation law and tax. We also offer business and wealth advisory services, which means we can provide a seamless and tax-effective offering to our clients.
-
Transfer pricing
Tax authorities are demanding transparency in international arrangements. We businesses comply with regulations and use transfer pricing as a strategic planning tool.
-
Audit methodology
Our five step audit methodology offers a high quality service wherever you are in the world and includes planning, risk assessment, testing internal controls, substantive testing, and concluding and reporting
-
Audit technology
We apply our audit methodology with an integrated set of software tools known as the Voyager suite. Our technology has been developed to produce quality audits that are effective and efficient.
-
Financial reporting advisory
Our financial reporting advisers have the expertise to help you deal with the constantly evolving regulatory environment.
-
Business architecture
Our business architects help businesses with disruptive conditions, business expansion and competitive challenges; the deployment of your strategy is critical to success.
-
Cloud services
Our team is led by cloud business experts who tailor services to the needs of your organisation, from strategy and implementation to ongoing services assurance.
-
Internal audit
Our internal audits deliver independent assurance over key controls within your riskiest processes, proving what works and what doesn’t and recommending improvements.
-
IT advisory
Our hands on product experience, extensive functional knowledge and industry insights help clients solve complex IT and technology issues
-
IT privacy and security
IT privacy and security should support your business strategy. Our pragmatic approach focuses on reducing cyber security risks specific to your organisation
-
Organisational & cultural change
The key to sustainable and future growth is a unified organisation operating within a strong cultural context, where transparency and communication are the priority for Kaimahi, and where visible leadership means walking the talk – but where does that journey begin?
-
Payroll assurance
Our specialist payroll assurance team can conduct a review of your payroll system configuration and processes, and then help you and your team to implement any necessary recalculations.
-
PCI DSS
Our information security specialists are approved Qualified Security Assessors (QSAs) that have been qualified by the PCI Security Standards Council to independently assess merchants and service providers.
-
Process improvement
As your organisation grows in size and complexity, processes that were once enabling often become cumbersome and inefficient. To maintain growth, your business must remain flexible, agile and profitable
-
Procurement/supply chain
Procurement and supply chain inputs will often dominate your balance sheet and constantly evolve for organisations to remain competitive and meet changing customer requirements
-
Project assurance
Major programmes and projects expose you to significant financial and reputational risk throughout their life cycle. Don’t let these risks become a reality.
-
Risk management
We understand that growing companies need to establish robust internal controls, and use information technology to effectively mitigate risk.
-
Robotic process automation (RPA)
RPA is emerging as the most sophisticated form of automation used to help businesses become more agile and remain competitive in the face of today’s ongoing digital disruption.
Using the Family Business to Fund a Relationship Property Settlement
With nearly 150,000 small to medium businesses operating in New Zealand, an ownership interest in a family business features in many relationship property settlements. The interest held in that business can represent a significant proportion of the relationship property, and in some cases it can make settlement proceedings considerably more complicated.
If there are other assets that can be used to offset the value of the business interest, or if the business is to be sold, then the process of allocating assets remains relatively straightforward. Even if there’s no actual sale price available, an independent valuation will provide the value of the business interest that can be used in dividing the assets.
However, if one of the parties wants to keep the business, and it forms a large proportion of the relationship property ‘pot’, it can add a great deal of time and complexity to the settlement process. In those circumstances, what might be needed is to further carve up the business value so that it can be distributed more easily.
To achieve this you will need to conduct a much more detailed assessment of the business, to identify any underlying assets that could be extracted. Depending on the nature and structure of the business there could be several impediments to realising and extracting that value.
If this seems like an arduous and daunting exercise, a specialist in business valuation and forensic accounting will be able to help. They will conduct a thorough evaluation and identify any issues, enabling you to remain focused on the other aspects of settlement proceedings.
Key Issues
There are several issues to consider when extracting assets from a family business in this context:
- Whether your client has the right to extract funds from the business
- Whether the business owns any assets that are capable of realisation
- How those assets could be converted into cash
- How any proceeds could be extracted from the business
- What effect the extraction of these assets will have on the value of the business
1. Does your client have the right to extract funds?
Not all business interests allow the extraction of funds, so the first step is to establish whether this is the case for your client. This requires very careful examination of any company ownership agreements: even though equity interests of over 50% usually confer this right, the approval of other shareholders might be needed - and this simply may not be forthcoming. (I recently valued a 51% equity business interest where the approval of 75% of shareholders was required for the payment of dividends or distributions. The remaining shareholders were hostile, which meant that there was no reasonable ability to extract funds).
Another way to realise funds is through the repayment of shareholder loans, particularly if they are repayable on demand. However, if your client only holds a minority interest, and no shareholder loans exist, it is unlikely that they will be able extract funds without the agreement of other shareholders, directors and funders.
2. Does the business own any assets that are capable of realisation?
If your client can extract funds from the business, the next step is to investigate whether the business owns any assets capable of being realised. In practice, this usually means identifying assets that could be realised without impacting the viability of the business.
Once again, this exercise is not always straightforward. For example, I recently valued a business that held a large cash balance, but this was mostly ‘locked up’ because it included seasonal working capital requirements, deposits held, and planned capital expenditure. I have also valued a number of financial services companies, where significant cash balances are held due to solvency criteria required by law - making them unavailable for distribution.
A full understanding of the business is necessary to accurately identify any realisable assets. Highly liquid assets (particularly cash) should not automatically be considered to be surplus to operations. Genuinely surplus assets may include:
- Land and buildings that are not being used by the business
- Cash not required by the business (e.g. term deposits)
- Surplus working capital (not forgetting to consider seasonal requirements)
- Investments, such as property, shares and other businesses
- Borrowing capacity (depending on the banks' willingness to lend money to fund a relationship property settlement)
Another important consideration here is timeframe: even where there are assets that could be sold, this process may cause unacceptable delay if the parties are looking for a quick settlement.
3. How can the business assets be converted into cash?
The next step, if there are assets available for realisation, is to decide how they will be converted into cash. They may be sold or simply transferred out of the business – or depending on circumstances your clients might consider other options such as:
- Further borrowing (secured against business assets)
- The sale and leaseback of land and buildings
- Using external funding rather than cash reserves to fund business commitments
- Factoring or discounting of any business debts
4. How can proceeds be extracted from the business?
When it comes to extracting funds following the realisation of assets, the most important issue to consider is the tax implications. At this stage it might be sensible to seek advice from a tax specialist regarding the structure of the settlement.
In my experience, dividends are the most common method of extracting funds, particularly when imputation credits are available. Depending on the business structure there may also be other options, such as the sale of shares or the repayment of shareholder loans.
5. How will extracting assets impact the value of the business?
Extracting assets or funds from the business will inevitably reduce its value. It is important to take this into consideration and adjust the valuation of the business interest accordingly once any funds have been paid out, to ensure there is no double counting in the settlement.
Summary
An interest in a family business can add real complexity to a relationship property settlement, where one of the parties wants to retain the business and the couple does not have other property of equal value. Extracting assets from the business may be a viable solution to this problem, but this is rarely a straightforward process. There are a number of important considerations, and a very thorough understanding of the business is needed to identify whether, and which, assets could be realised. Expert accounting and valuation advice and a full assessment of the circumstances will help you to reach a practical solution and achieve a fair division of assets acceptable to both parties.
This article appeared in Volume 16 Issue 3 of The Family Advocate.