-
Compliance and audit reviews
From mandates, best practice procedures or accreditations, to simply gaining peace of mind, our technical and industry experts have you covered.
-
External audit
Strengthen business and stakeholder confidence with professionally verified results and insights.
-
Financial reporting advisory
Deep expertise to help you navigate New Zealand’s constantly evolving regulatory environment.
-
Corporate tax
Identify tax issues, risks and opportunities in your organisation, and implement strategies to improve your bottom line.
-
Indirect tax
Stay on top of the indirect taxes that can impact your business at any given time.
-
Individual tax
Preparing today to help you invest in tomorrow.
-
Private business tax structuring
Find the best tax structure for your business.
-
Tax disputes
In a dispute with Inland Revenue or facing an audit? Don’t go it alone.
-
Research & development
R&D tax incentives are often underused and misunderstood – is your business maximising opportunities for making claims?
-
Management reporting
You’re doing well, but could you be doing even better? Discover the power of management reporting.
-
Financial reporting advisory
Deep expertise to help you navigate New Zealand’s constantly evolving regulatory environment.
-
Succession planning
When it comes to a business strategy that’s as important as succession planning, you can’t afford to leave things to chance.
-
Trust management
Fresh perspectives, practical solutions and flexible support for trusts and estate planning.
-
Forecasting and budgeting
Prepare for every likely situation with robust budgeting and forecasting models.
-
Outsourced accounting services
An extension of your team when you need us, so you can focus your time, energy and passion on your business.
-
Setting up in New Zealand
Looking to set up a business in New Zealand? You’ve come to the right place.
-
Policy reviews & development
Turn your risks into strengths with tailored policies that protect, guide and empower your business.
-
Performance improvement
Every business has untapped potential. Unlock yours.
-
Programme & project management
Successfully execute mission-critical changes to your organisation.
-
Strategy
Make a choice about your vision and purpose, where you will play and how you will win – now and into the future.
-
Risk
Manage risks with confidence to support your strategy.
-
Cloud services
Leverage the cloud to keep your data safe, operate more efficiently, reduce costs and create a better experience for your employees and clients.
-
Data analytics
Use your data to make better business decisions.
-
IT assurance
Are your IT systems reliable, safe and compliant?
-
Cyber resilience
As the benefits technology can deliver to your business increases, so too do the opportunities for cybercriminals.
-
Virtual asset advisory
Helping you navigate the world of virtual currencies and decentralised financial systems.
-
Virtual CSO
Security leadership and expertise when you need it.
-
Debt advisory
Raise, refinance, restructure or manage debt to achieve the optimal funding structure for your organisation.
-
Financial modelling
Understand the impact of your decisions before you make them.
-
Raising finance
Access the best source of funding for your business with a sound business strategy and rigorous planning.
-
Business valuations
Valuable decisions require valued insights.
-
Complex and international services
Navigate the complexities of multi-jurisdictional insolvencies.
-
Corporate insolvency
Achieve fair and orderly outcomes if your business – or part of it - is facing insolvency.
-
Independent business review
Is your business viable today? Will it be viable tomorrow? Give your business a health check to find out.
-
Litigation support
Straight forward advice from trusted advisors to support litigation and arbitration matters, expert determinations and other specialist hearings.
-
Business valuations
Valuable decisions require valued insights.
-
Forensic accounting & dispute advisory
Understand the true values, numbers and dollars at stake, as well as your obligations and rights to ensure value is preserved and complexities are managed.
-
Expert witness
Our expert witnesses analyse, interpret, summarise and present complex financial and business-related issues which are understandable and properly supported.
-
Investigation services
A fast and customised response when misconduct occurs in your business.
A level playing field for capital gains
A heated Auckland property market has prompted the Government to target speculators and foreign buyers in this week’s Budget announcement. A capital gains tax will be introduced on property sold within two years of purchase with exemptions: the property is the seller’s main home, it is an inheritance or deceased estate, or it’s transferred as part of a relationship settlement.
The announcement has been made despite the fact that speculators are already subject to tax on any gains made from sales of property – as are those whose business comprises dealing in property - and their associates (with a general ten year limitation).
Whether someone is a speculator or simply a genuine investor is a vexed question, and it depends on a range of factors, some of which can only be divined after the fact. As has occurred in previous years, Budget 2015 is expected to see additional resources allocated to Inland Revenue to investigate property deals and pursue those who cross the broad grey line that often delineates the taxable and the tax-free.
Land transactions are an attractive, low-hanging fruit to target for a capital gains tax. New Zealand operates a computerised land registry system that makes tracking ownership (and changes thereof) relatively easy. There’s also a certain amount of political acceptance based on the current housing crisis, regardless of its causes.
It sometimes seems that the ill-will generated by the unwelcome consequences of speculator behaviour spills over and taints genuine property investors. Yet what is it that investors do that is so different from any other form of capital investment?
Landlords pay tax on rental income, after deducting expenses incurred in earning that income, such as insurance, rates, repairs, and interest incurred on debt used to acquire the property. Provided property is not acquired with the intention of sale, and is not caught by any of the other specific provisions relating to land transactions, any capital gain is not taxed.
Compare that with a person who buys a business. Just like landlords, they pay tax on income, with a deduction for expenses incurred in earning that income, such as cost of goods, utilities, and wages – and interest incurred on funds borrowed to finance the business. On selling the business, any capital gain (usually represented by goodwill) is generally not taxed. However, a person in the business of developing businesses for sale would be taxed.
And someone who buys shares pays tax on dividends earned. There’s a deduction for costs incurred in earning that income, such as portfolio management and accounting costs, as well as any interest costs on funds borrowed to acquire the shares. Unless a person is a dealer, there’s generally no tax charged on any capital gains incurred (although capital gains on foreign shares can be taxed under a separate regime that can tax even unrealised capital gains).
In some ways, land already suffers from a tax disadvantage compared with other investments because of the specific provisions that can rope in other transactions. In particular, the “associated person” rules mean that the activities and proclivities of Taxpayer A affect the tax treatment of Taxpayer B. That generally does not occur in other capital investment contexts.
It’s not so much the tax treatment that gives property a perceived advantage over other investments. It’s the perception of the security of the investment and the willingness of financial institutions to provide funding. Bankers give a different response if asked to lend $500,000 on the security of shares to be purchased with the funds compared to being asked the same thing about a rental property.
A number of other suggestions have been put forward for taxing property investment, ranging from a land tax to a deemed rate of return. There is some precedent for this, as the concepts run very close to the fair dividend rate method applicable to certain investments in overseas shares.
Whatever happens, it’s important to remember that land is simply one form of capital investment. Using tax to address issues that are less the making of perceived tax advantages than they are of surrounding economic conditions runs the risk of being seen as a knee-jerk reaction.
Further enquiries, please contact:
Geordie Hooft
Partner, Tax
Grant Thornton New Zealand
T +64 (0)3 379 9580
E geordie.hooft@nz.gt.com