• Skip to content
  • Skip to navigation
  • Meet our people
  • Insights
  • Careers
  • Events
  • Locations
  • English
Global site
  • Global site
  • Africa
  • Americas
  • Asia Pacific
  • Europe
  • Middle East
    Services
    Audit
    Knowledge and integrity you can rely on.
    See Overview
    • Compliance and audit reviews
      From mandates, best practice procedures or accreditations, to simply gaining peace of mind, our technical and industry experts have you covered.
    • External audit
      Strengthen business and stakeholder confidence with professionally verified results and insights.
    • Financial reporting advisory
      Deep expertise to help you navigate New Zealand’s constantly evolving regulatory environment.
    Tax
    The business tax landscape is transforming. Are you ready?
    See Overview
    • Corporate tax
      Identify tax issues, risks and opportunities in your organisation, and implement strategies to improve your bottom line.
    • Indirect tax
      Stay on top of the indirect taxes that can impact your business at any given time.
    • Individual tax
      Preparing today to help you invest in tomorrow.
    • Private business tax structuring
      Find the best tax structure for your business.
    • Tax disputes
      In a dispute with Inland Revenue or facing an audit? Don’t go it alone.
    • Research & development
      R&D tax incentives are often underused and misunderstood – is your business maximising opportunities for making claims?
    Business services
    Tailored solutions to help you navigate challenges, seize opportunities and realise your ambitions.
    See Overview
    • Management reporting
      You’re doing well, but could you be doing even better? Discover the power of management reporting.
    • Financial reporting advisory
      Deep expertise to help you navigate New Zealand’s constantly evolving regulatory environment.
    • Succession planning
      When it comes to a business strategy that’s as important as succession planning, you can’t afford to leave things to chance.
    • Trust management
      Fresh perspectives, practical solutions and flexible support for trusts and estate planning.
    • Forecasting and budgeting
      Prepare for every likely situation with robust budgeting and forecasting models.
    • Outsourced accounting services
      An extension of your team when you need us, so you can focus your time, energy and passion on your business.
    • Setting up in New Zealand
      Looking to set up a business in New Zealand? You’ve come to the right place.
    Management consulting
    Access experts who can help you build capability, tackle challenges and opportunities, and create lasting success.
    See Overview
    • Policy reviews & development
      Turn your risks into strengths with tailored policies that protect, guide and empower your business.
    • Performance improvement
      Every business has untapped potential. Unlock yours.
    • Programme & project management
      Successfully execute mission-critical changes to your organisation.
    • Strategy
      Make a choice about your vision and purpose, where you will play and how you will win – now and into the future.
    • Risk
      Manage risks with confidence to support your strategy.
    Digital advisory
    Start or enhance your digital transformation journey or latest IT project.
    See Overview
    • Cloud services
      Leverage the cloud to keep your data safe, operate more efficiently, reduce costs and create a better experience for your employees and clients.
    • Data analytics
      Use your data to make better business decisions.
    • IT assurance
      Are your IT systems reliable, safe and compliant?
    • Cyber resilience
      As the benefits technology can deliver to your business increases, so too do the opportunities for cybercriminals.
    • Virtual asset advisory
      Helping you navigate the world of virtual currencies and decentralised financial systems.
    • Virtual CSO
      Security leadership and expertise when you need it.
    Finance & funding
    Unlock sources of finance, present your case to potential funders and negotiate long-term sustainable relationships.
    See Overview
    • Debt advisory
      Raise, refinance, restructure or manage debt to achieve the optimal funding structure for your organisation.
    • Financial modelling
      Understand the impact of your decisions before you make them.
    • Raising finance
      Access the best source of funding for your business with a sound business strategy and rigorous planning.
    • Business valuations
      Valuable decisions require valued insights.
    Insolvency
    Take an early and proactive approach if insolvency is on the horizon.
    See Overview
    • Complex and international services
      Navigate the complexities of multi-jurisdictional insolvencies.
    • Corporate insolvency
      Achieve fair and orderly outcomes if your business – or part of it - is facing insolvency.
    Restructuring & turnaround
    Practical solutions for distressed situations.
    See Overview
    • Independent business review
      Is your business viable today? Will it be viable tomorrow? Give your business a health check to find out.
    • Litigation support
      Straight forward advice from trusted advisors to support litigation and arbitration matters, expert determinations and other specialist hearings.
    Forensics
    When risk becomes reality, take rapid protective action to get back to business as usual.
    See Overview
    • Business valuations
      Valuable decisions require valued insights.
    • Forensic accounting & dispute advisory
      Understand the true values, numbers and dollars at stake, as well as your obligations and rights to ensure value is preserved and complexities are managed.
    • Expert witness
      Our expert witnesses analyse, interpret, summarise and present complex financial and business-related issues which are understandable and properly supported.
    • Investigation services
      A fast and customised response when misconduct occurs in your business.
    Industries
    • Aged care & retirement villages
    • Financial services
    • Not for profit
    • Property & construction
    • Public sector
    Aged care & retirement villages
    Helping aged care and retirement village operators deliver on their mission and purpose in an increasingly demanding environment.
    See Overview
    Financial services
    Our unique offering to the financial services sector may be the catalyst you need to take your business forward, safely and prosperously.
    See Overview
    Not for profit
    The true measure of society is how it treats its most vulnerable people. Your success is vital to ensuring our country remains a fair and civil one.
    See Overview
    Property & construction
    Minimise your risk and cost while maximising your returns for the best chance of success in today’s market.
    See Overview
    Public sector
    Our public sector team goes beyond expectations so you can too.
    See Overview
    • English
    1. Home
    2. Press releases
    3. 2012
    4. HMF statutory managers reject claims by investor group

    HMF statutory managers reject claims by investor group

    07 Nov 2012

    Press releases

    • 2022 2022
      • Armstrong Downes Commercial 2012 Limited (ADC) appoints Grant Thornton as liquidators
      • Grant Thornton New Zealand announces partnership with Syndex
    • 2021
    • 2020
    • 2019
    • 2018
    • 2017
    • 2016
    • 2015
    • 2014
    • 2013
    • 2012

    The unofficial Investor Liaison Group for Hubbard Management Funds (HMF) is misrepresenting the facts of the situation,” say the HMF Statutory Managers.

    “The claim that the statutory managers are  responsible for a loss of value of $40 million is simply incorrect and the real  position has been made clear in our Reports to investors.

    “Despite several meetings with the Investor Liaison Group to answer their questions and confirmation from them that they understood what we were talking about when we met, they clearly do not  understand the situation otherwise they would not be making these unfounded  claims that will upset other investors whom they do not represent.

    “The facts are that, as at March 2010, the  fair value of the identified assets of HMF was $60m not the $83m reflected on Mr Hubbard’s statements to investors. He had over stated the value of the Fund by $23m. This value is after recognition of a loss of over $4m on an investment in Southbury Group, a company controlled by Mr Hubbard. 

    “Since that date a further cash shortage of $6.5 million has been identified after another related party transaction was investigated. Additionally, a further $7 million of assets are being claimed by financiers and the Hubbard family. 

    “These factors total over $36m and were totally outside of our control. 

    “The remaining $4 million (taking the total to $40m) represents a variety of market movements and costs over the  period. 

    “The distribution of the Funds to investors is not straightforward. Whichever distribution option was adopted, one group of  HMF investors was going to be disadvantaged over others. 

    “Where the right method is not clear, the process is for the Statutory Managers to file an application in the Courts suggesting one of the possible methods be applied in order that other Counsel can argue before a Judge, the merits of another method. The Court makes the decision.

    “We made submissions to the High Court for a determination on the Personal Investment Plan (PIP) while we ensured other lawyers submitted alternative methods that advantaged the investors they represented.  Ultimately, the PIP method was not favoured by the Court and an alternative method is now being worked through under the guidance of the High Court.

    “For those investors who would be disadvantaged under the methodology adopted by the court, we advised that should they wish to appeal the ruling, they may want to seek independent legal  advice. We then provided details of several lawyers independent of the other legal teams, one of whom was familiar with the PIP methodology, having  previously worked for the law firm representing the Statutory Managers.  Investors chose which lawyer if any, they wanted representing them. This was a responsible approach given we could not be part of any appeal.

    “The figures on likely returns to investors referred to by the Investor Liaison Group in their complaint to the Minister were in fact requested by them late last year. With these figures investors could be informed and understand the impacts of the PIP and pooling approaches to the distribution of the funds in advance of the court hearing last May. 

    “We made it clear these figures were provisional, and came with a number of caveats noting that they were, at best indicative as there were a number of claims by others, and the investments were subject to market movements. To this extent only are they inaccurate as they depend on future uncertain events. 

    “It is only when all investments are realised that final figures will be made available. This may take considerable time as the nature of some investments is long term. Our intention was to provide the best available information to investors in an  attempt to provide transparency as to the possible impacts of a court  hearing. 

    The Investor Liaison Group complained about the fees for the work on HMF. The fees for unwinding HMF are updated and provided in each Statutory Managers’ report to investors. For the sake of transparency we requested that they are reviewed by an independent reviewer appointed by the Ministry and include legal and associated fees as well as our own fees. We note that Mr Hubbard also charged fees.

    “As the Statutory Managers we understand that the time to unwind the Fund and return capital to investors is causing difficulties for some. However, as Statutory Managers, we operate with integrity and have a duty to act in the best interests of all HMF investors. We are committed to returning as much of their capital back to them as we can, as soon as we can and we will,”concluded the Statutory Managers.

    Further enquiries, please contact:

    Michael  Dunlop
    Acumen Republic
    M +64 (0)275 747 587
    D +64 (0)4 494 5142
    E mdunlop@acumenrepublic.com

    CONNECT CONNECT

    • Contact us
    • Meet our people
    • Careers
    • Alumni
    • Request for sponsorship
    • Locations

    ABOUT ABOUT

    • About Grant Thornton
    • Insights
    • Press

    LEGAL LEGAL

    • Privacy
    • Disclaimer
    • Sitemap

    Follow usFollow us

    © 2025 Grant Thornton International Ltd (GTIL) - All rights reserved. "Grant Thornton” refers to the brand under which the Grant Thornton member firms provide assurance, tax and advisory services to their clients and/or refers to one or more member firms, as the context requires. GTIL and the member firms are not a worldwide partnership. GTIL and each member firm is a separate legal entity. Services are delivered by the member firms. GTIL does not provide services to clients. GTIL and its member firms are not agents of, and do not obligate, one another and are not liable for one another’s acts or omissions.